BACK IN THE 70S MY PARTNER AND I WROTE THE BOOK ON BOOTLEG RECORDS. I DECIDED TO WRITE THE BOOK TO SHARE THOSE FUN-FILLED TIMES. I’LL POST IT CHAPTER BY CHAPTER OVER THE NEXT LITTLE WHILE. HERE WE GO WITH
ELVIS VS. THE BOOTLEG BOYS
ELVIS BOOTLEGS
The Vic Colonna Story
(How I made records for fun, profit, and one–to–five)
© 2009
William Samuel Theaker
Prologue
I slammed the car into reverse, lunged back down the alley, jammed it into drive, and sped away. Travis’ words were roaring in my ears: “Two guys in dark suits were here looking for you.”
TWO guys? I was almost flattered. I guess it was either get me or fight organized crime.
Traffic lights and intersections were a blur. Green lights, yellow lights, just–turned–red lights all looked the same; I was on the lam!
Two guys in dark suits? I almost wished I’d been there. Would they have yelled, “Take the needle off the record and step away from the machine with your hands in the air”?
Criminy, I wasn’t a drug lord; I ran a little record store. Oh, and I made Elvis Presley bootleg records for a few years before that. Okay, I grant you, legally I had no right whatsoever. But morally? Damn right! RCA, Elvis’ record company, had made it their policy to treat Elvis fans like petulant adolescents! (When’s the last time you listened to “Elvis Sings For Children and Grownups Too”? Ever waste your money on an RCA “Electronically Re–Processed” record? Ever buy an Elvis 8–LP set, discover four were warped, and be told the ONLY way to have them replaced was to mail them to RCA at YOUR OWN expense?)
I created QUALITY Elvis records! Full color covers, banded cuts, liner notes, true mono or stereo—and sold them at a very reasonable price. Conversely, while I was doing this, the best RCA could come up with was a previously unreleased version of “Beyond the Reef”—THREE YEARS after Elvis died!
RCA should be indicted; I should be knighted!
Keep in mind, this was the very same company that, in 1959, THREW AWAY a warehouse full of their recording artists’ outtakes, including almost all of Elvis’ priceless ‘50s material! (Some fool RCA VP had decided they needed more shelf space!) All I did was take similar outtakes and create 23 classic Elvis albums! (I once read that when Elvis saw some he was quite amused.)
But, I bit Nipper and now he was biting back.
I checked the rear–view mirror for the hundredth time and changed lanes. Oh, the irony: I made records, I sold records, and suddenly the FBI wants to GIVE me a record.
It was December 9, 1982, my son Patrick’s eighth birthday, and I was in full getaway mode, tearing down the freeway in a beat–up station wagon filled with used records. All because “two guys in dark suits” had just changed everything forever.
Chapter One
And so it begins…
I picked through my parent’s attic back in West Hartford, Connecticut when we visited in the fall of 1974, Vicki and I. We were newly–wed; Vicki was seven months pregnant. My mother happened to notice; I headed upstairs and left them alone in the kitchen to sort that one out. I entered my room, went into the walk–in closet, opened the attic door, and climbed the steps.
Up there were things I had not visited since I left for college a dozen years before. There was my collection of baseball cards, remnants of my once–massive collection of 45’s, and the one thing I had judiciously guarded and that was 99% intact: my collection of Elvis Presley 45’s and EP’s. Elvis has been my favorite male singer since he burst onto the national scene in 1956.
I bundled the baseball cards and the Elvis records into my suitcase. When we got back to Los Angeles I decided the baseball cards had to go; we needed the money. I took them to a Santa Monica Boulevard sports memorabilia shop and walked out with $100. One of them was the 1951 Topps Mickey Mantle rookie card that sold for $225,000 years later. I have no regrets; that deal dramatically changed my life. The money was tucked away; it would be used only when desperately needed.
The Elvis records were filled with memories and I decided to keep them. Nostalgia was beginning to play a role in my life. I planned to reconstitute my Elvis collection, get all those that I mysteriously never purchased. This decided, I wondered just where to start my quest? I began scouring record stores. Try as I might, I found but a scant few of the Elvis records I wanted; most were in unsuitable condition.
In a bookstore on Melrose Avenue, in the heart of the Antique District of Los Angeles, there were boxes of records under every table. A fellow named Brian Burney rented space from the bookstore owner so he could display his wares. Where else to put them? Thanks to Brian, I acquired a dozen 45s I needed. Brian will be back soon, in a starring role. About this time I realized there were many other Elvis collectors out there; not much later I was trying to add to everyone else’s collection.
Next, I discovered The Recycler. The paper was distributed every Thursday morning, starting promptly at nine; in 1975 it was in its infancy. The Recycler let individual sellers list items for free (commercial businesses were charged); many Thursday mornings I was waiting outside their offices for that week’s offerings.
One week’s paper listed an Elvis collection; I called and made an appointment to go look at it that night. We drove to Pomona, some thirty miles distant, and found a complete collection of 45’s, all with picture sleeves; all the EP’s; many duplicates, and the elusive Sun 78’s. The asking price was $400. I left a $100 deposit (that desperation money) and promised to be back tomorrow.
One small problem remained, just where the heck was I going to get the other $300? A trip to Household Finance solved that problem; I went from Elvis collector to one with an Elvis collection overnight. I did not think there was much more I needed; I was almost done. I suddenly had a surfeit of Elvis records, since my purchase included duplicates of many of the 45s. This was trading fodder; I could haggle with other collectors for the items I did not have. It was not as easy as I thought, for I soon found out there were variations, promo–only items, reissues, and even a few bootlegs.
All that I really knew about bootlegs was that years before I had purchased an album titled “Last Live Show” that boasted the Beatles at Shea Stadium. It had an 8½ x 11 Xeroxed sheet under the shrink–wrap, a plain white cover, and the label was blank. All I heard was screaming, hysterical fans and way, way back in the distance something resembling a Beatles tune. Such was my experience with bootlegs; I never purchased another.
Not until I heard about, from another collector, an LP called “TV Guide Presents Elvis” and a man named Paul Dowling. I called Paul, not quite sure how to proceed, but wanting to pump him for information about collecting and about this record he had made. Not in the least aloof or pretentious, he came across as genuine and sincere; he answered my questions about Elvis collecting, offered invaluable information, and suggested other collectors to contact. When it came to the TV Guide record, something I found quite intriguing, Paul mentioned he was hoping to make another bootleg—this one a document encompassing Elvis’ first six television appearances on The Dorsey Brothers Show in early 1956. Huh? Never knew that. My first recollection of Elvis on TV was the famed Ed Sullivan appearances. It turned out the first Sullivan show was Elvis’ tenth bit of national TV exposure. I sure had lots to learn. Paul and I quickly became good telephone pals. At that point, Paul had only managed to acquire three of the six Dorsey appearances; I set about to find the others.
Chapter Two
Brian’s song
During that search, fate intervened; I chanced upon some unreleased Elvis material from the 1968 TV Special. This was a bootlegger’s dream: fans knew of it, thanks to Jerry Hopkins biography, “Elvis,” but RCA never released a note. A phone call to Brian Burney, wondering if he had anything new, revealed he had purchased some “test pressings” and was holding them for me. Test pressings are routinely made before the actual LP goes into production to verify accuracy; I expected to find something akin to white–label promos. What I was actually presented with was nothing like that.
Brian now had a record store in the exclusive Larchmont section of Los Angeles. I walked in, saw Brian was with a customer, and started to flip through the records in the bins. “Hi Sam.” and “Hi Brian” passed between us as another customer stepped up to the counter with his purchase. I continued looking at film and Broadway soundtracks that were of no interest to me; the mating dance continued. Finally, some twenty minutes later, Brian looked over and said, “I have those records in the back. Let me get them for you.” He returned a moment later and handed me three “acetates” that not only did not have labels, two of them were one–sided (Acetates, much thicker than vinyl, are records cut in the studio directly from tapes. They deteriorate rapidly after a few plays and are generally intended as a quick means to get a sample of material on record for a producer or bigwig to assess). In the dead wax area, where the label goes, written with white china marker, was: “Elvis I,” Elvis II,” on the one–sided exemplars, “Guitar Man/Elvis I” on the double–sided acetate. “These are interesting. What’s on them?” Brian replied, “I’m not sure, I haven’t played them.” He said something about the “Guitar Man” album. I nodded, knowingly, knowing one thing for sure: there was not any Elvis album titled “Guitar Man” (there would be, years later, one of those posthumous compilations). Brian actually had multiple copies of these acetates; where they came from did not occur to me at that time, but the answer would later astound. It should have been a simple matter to play these discs and see what they contained. However, Brian did not have a record player in the store. This, coupled with Brian’s complete lack of knowledge about rock—he specialized in soundtracks, show tunes, and classical—made “A–1 Record Finders” unique. I hemmed, hawed, yawed, and yawned, and tried to appear as uninterested as possible; I did my best to downplay their worth. “If only they had test pressing labels.” I moaned. I finally asked Brian to put a price tag on them. He thought for a moment, came back with ten dollars each, and I hesitantly agreed. I would like to think I took my time leaving; there was probably a dust cloud where I once stood. I bolted for the car, headed home to Glendale—the longest forty–five–minute drive of my life—and rushed into the house
I arrived shortly before eight o’clock, just in time to call Vicki, ask how she was doing, and say good night—it was August of 1975, a scant two years after we arrived in California; Vicki was back in Philadelphia showing off Patrick, then eight months old, to all her friends and relatives. That done, I went into the living room, turned on the stereo, and settled back to hear what I had found. I was listening to parts of the recording issued after Elvis’ triumphant return 1968 television special. This was a part studio (live before an audience of 300), part soundstage production that heralded Elvis’ return to center stage. For years he had been visible only in the movies; as they became staler, so did his image. The British Invasion relegated him to a rock ‘n’ roll footnote. Four years on, it was time to see if he still had drawing power. I also imagine it was time to make some money; his record sales were at an all–time low.
As I listened, I retrieved my copy of the RCA album. I remembered a medley from the show as: “Nothingville/Big Boss Man/Guitar Man” but this went straight from “Nothingville” to “Guitar Man.” I wondered if I was correct about the ordering of the songs; I would have bet the house that “Big Boss Man” was the middle part of this trio. Still, I opted to check. I found the album, headed back into the living room reading the track listing, and “Guitar Man” ended with a sudden switch to some calliope–like racket. Before I could begin to wonder what was going on, a sultry female voice began signing the opening verse of “Let Yourself Go” with a deliberately brazen, sexual innuendo. A couple lines later, Elvis came in. The arrangement was incredible, nothing like the lame version of this song heard in the movie, “Speedway.” I could not believe my luck; I was privy to the infamous “bordello scene” that had been planned as part of the TV Special but later snipped. (All because Col. Parker’s insisted his boy couldn’t be portrayed behaving in such an outlandish manner.)
I had an unreleased Elvis song! Well, almost, there was that movie version. This was nothing like that; this was raw, vintage Elvis, the one that had set teenage boys’ lips curling and teen girls’ hearts thumping a dozen years before. This was it! I did just what you might have expected: first I sat down in the middle of the living–room floor, then I lay flat on my back holding the TV Special record straight above me, and I roared. And I laughed. And I cried out, “Yes, Yes, Yes!” I spent the next few hours calling all the Elvis fans and collectors I knew, playing for them what I had found. None complained. More than a few were already in bed, a few sounded a bit irksome when they answered the phone in the middle of the night; none were anything but ecstatic by the conclusion of the call. So goes the wacky world of Elvis devotees.
I had chanced upon the ultimate find and now I wondered if there could be more; more than that, I wondered just where this stuff came from? How did Brian ever get hold of these things? I asked Brian; he told me that a television executive who lived in Beverly Hills was transferring to New York and unloaded, rather than cart with him, his collection of classical records, eight thousand of them. Brian skimmed through the batch, determined they were worthy of purchase, and trucked them to his warehouse. Over the next few weeks while sorting and pricing he discovered, tucked in amongst Brahms, Beethoven, and Bach, these acetates. “Who was this guy?” I inquired. Brian told me his name was Bob Finkel. That name rang a bell. I pulled out the RCA album, looked on the back, and saw why the name sounded familiar. Robert Finkel was the executive producer of the ’68 TV Special. It all made sense: the original taping would be edited into the finished version of the show. Robert Finkel could not be present every minute, so acetates were made for him to critique at home. He must have stored them in his record racks, and that was that. Placed there years before, and then forgotten, was the only conclusion. Had he remembered, they would have been removed before he called Brian. Thanks for the memory lapse, Mr. Finkel. Thanks for thinking of me, Brian. Time to work out a deal with Paul Dowling.
Chapter Three
Working for a living
Since I first spoke to Paul about the “TV Guide Presents Elvis” LP I had fancied what it would be like to be a bootlegger. I could do it; I was sure of it. Of course, I needed something to bootleg, and did I not just acquire it? But then what? I was looking at this as a long–term project, not just a minor flirtation. So I sat down to think about things; I put a plan in motion. First, to make some money from this unexpected find, I contacted a few diehard collectors: Andy Kern from Texas and Anna Labbate from New York were sure things; a few others took some convincing. I wound up selling six of the extra seven sets for two hundred dollars each.
A handsome profit it was; big money, for a kid making just over four bucks an hour at Kaiser Hospital. While trying to unload the extras, I also contacted Paul. I shipped him a set for $30; all I asked was that he wait about nine months before releasing the material on a bootleg. This would let enough time pass for the obvious explanation—he acquired it from someone else. When those chosen few who thought they had a near–exclusive on their hands found out the material was being offered for general sale, they would not get upset. Plus, they had the “originals.” I thought the world should hear this stuff, not just a few people. I was glad to make some money; not yet ready to propose Paul and I work together on a bootleg. Paul is a man of his word, all went according to plan, and when “The ’68 Comeback” appeared, nary a word was raised in protest. My friendship with Paul was cemented; next time we would work together.
That television special beamed in 1968 was back in the days when one sponsor, in this case Singer (the sewing machine company), could afford to foot the bill for an entire show. The actual title of the show was, as I recalled, “Singer Presents Elvis.” That was confirmed when we later acquired a 16mm color print of the show. Paul bought it shortly after we started making bootlegs; that began our entry into the film business. “Singer Presents Elvis” was not a snappy title for a record. Years later, it was generally acknowledged that this show was what put Elvis not just back on the map, but back on top. The British invasion was in full swing; heavy metal just around the corner (thanks to the Kinks, Steppenwolf, and the prescient tones of Black Sabbath), psychedelic rock flourished, and amidst all this was the once and former king. Elvis had nary a hit for three years, an eroding fan base, and the movies had gone stale. In an NBC minute he was back where he always was. Brash, bold, bedecked in black leather, and strutting his stuff, he faced the invited crowd, 300 for each of four shows filmed in NBC’s largest studio, and they went gaga. The girls, carefully chosen to surround the stage (more like a boxing ring without ropes and corner girls squeezed into every available inch), swooned. The mood was infectious. It was a comeback of the first order and Paul noted this with the title of his LP. From that day forward fans have always referred to the show as “The ’68 Comeback,” and that is exactly what it was.
About that night: I have always referred to it as the greatest back–to–back opening lines in TV history. At eight o’clock, the NBC peacock (with the off–screen announcement, “The following program is brought to you in living color…”) faded, and Elvis’ face filled the screen. A split second later the half smile turned to the trademark sneer and he greeted those tuned in with, “If you’re looking for trouble, you came to the right place.” One for the girls, and just how you top that remains a mystery. Talk about setting a mood, what a way to let the audience know they were in for a treat. The camera pulled back to reveal “ELVIS” in giant letters; platforms just behind the letters were filled with guitar–wielding rockers dressed like Elvis, shown in silhouette. The boys certainly cheered too, but at nine o’clock they would really have something that would make them sit up and take notice. Elvis ended with “If I Can Dream” and that was the song, written especially for the show, which put him back on the charts to stay. It was merely a short break in those days, and no previews for what was to follow. The eight o’clock process repeated itself, the same peacock preened, the same announcement intoned, the same fade–away, and a different picture filled the screen: There, in gentle repose, was Brigitte Bardot, sex–kitten supreme, lying across a velvet loveseat, propped up on her left elbow, and she purred, “How would you like to spend the next hour with me?” They will never top those two opening lines, ever. And no two bootleggers will ever again rise to the dizzying heights Paul and I enjoyed.
I had made the first step in establishing a solid relationship with Paul. He was as knowledgeable as they come in everything Elvis. He was easy to get along with, and eager to make more bootlegs. What he lacked was material. I had ideas; it was just a matter of time. Those three Dorsey shows proved elusive for a bit. However, my job at Kaiser had a fringe benefit: I could call anywhere. I was a lab technician and roamed all over the hospital collecting blood samples. That gave me free run of the phones on every floor. My fingers walked the world.
I called everywhere and everyone. One call led to another and another. After a couple months I was getting discouraged; then a call to some obscure collector in Canada produced results. He had the Dorsey shows, all of them. We hammered out a trade, I sent what he requested, and I received the tapes a few days later. Within a few months I had quit my job at Kaiser and was wishing there were more hours in the day. I was finding out what it meant to work for a living.